An argument in favor of animal experimentation

But, for the most part, the overwhelming instances of animal exploitation are ruled out from the start in Regan's theory, where, under Singer's view, they are all ruled in unless Singer can demonstrate that the aggregation of consequences indicates otherwise.

I have been unable to find a single instance in which animal rights advocates support the notion that there is any possibility of immediate action that will result in the immediate abolition of all institutionalized exploitation.

Singer acknowledges that although in the first edition of Animal Liberation, he rejected this view as "nonsense," id. Do these theories, which propose ideal moral states, have prescriptions for how to effect incremental change in order to achieve the state of affairs for animals that would be required under the ideal state.

He certainly lost it on logic, though he probably won on rhetoric and organization as he always does. Eventually, the symposium was cancelled and Singer's invitation consequently withdrawn.

In this overview of the topic, the views of each of these thinkers and their place in contemporary animal welfare and rights movements will be briefly set out. That is, if Singer were able to construct his ideal moral world for animals, animals would be treated in such a way that their treatment would maximize the pleasure and preference satisfaction for all beings who are affected.

Assume that animal advocates criticize experiments in which animals are burned at a high temperature without the benefit of anesthesia for five minutes. Although interests may be balanced, some interests, such as the right of the worker not to be arbitrarily killed by the boss, cannot be traded away because those interests simply are not on the table.

The only way that this will change is if the characterization of animals as property changes and moves closer to personhood--which is another way of saying that animals cannot have any non- basic rights until they get the basic right of not being regarded exclusively as means to human ends.

Now I am sad about it to this day because of my stupid mouth. The first group of protesters was distressed by this second, more aggressive group.

Stop Adding Zeroes

Flew [ audiovideobook ] Craig gives his standard arguments Kalam, fine-tuning, morality, Resurrection, personal revelation. Based on the structural defects of animal welfare and the legal and political institutions that enforce some version of animal welfare based on the property status of animals, there are probably some compelling reasons for an animal rights advocate to spend her limited time and resources on these more indirect incremental changes through various forms of education, protest, and boycotts.

And, although many people will tolerate the payment of low wages to workers, few would similarly tolerate human slavery. Drug C killed all the mice and rats.

Steps for initial bed preparation include: Not so trivial anymore, eh. The second aspect is that, in seeking this long-term goal, the rights advocate cannot endorse the sacrifice of fundamental interests of some animals today in the hope that some animals tomorrow will no longer be treated as the property of human owners.

Dairy Estrogen & Male Fertility

There was, however, no consideration of this by the new welfarists; nor, as far as I am aware, was any such consideration urged by Singer. Do you really want our governments to kill 6 people every year so you can continue to eat meat.

He added that "[i]f we ever do find a better system, I'll be happy to call myself an anti-capitalist". I was a meat for every meal and beef jerky for a snack guy. PETA's action alerts allows you to easily contact companies, universities, government agencies, and others to improve the lives of animals used for food, clothing, experimentation and entertainment.

Because animals as distant from humans as mice and rats share many physiological and genetic similarities with humans, animal experimentation can be tremendously helpful for furthering medical science. However, there is an ongoing debate about the ethics of animal experimentation. I also think it’s probably because they’re trying to transition to the diet.

Veganism is a philosophy, and I subscribe to many of the parts of veganism, though I myself am not vegan. Dec 08,  · Animal experimentation A difficult issue But the argument is about whether the experiments are morally right or wrong.

The general moral character of the experimenter is irrelevant. Eight Arguments in Favor of Eating Meat and Objections Thereto. Most of the following eight arguments came from a Contemporary Moral Issues class that I taught at the University of Wisconsin-Madison in the Fall of I asked the students to give me their best arguments in favor of eating meat, and these are the results.

Animal Welfare. Animal research can only be carried out when there is no viable non-animal alternative. Tweet this! The 3Rs (replace, reduce, refine) guide how animals are used in biomedical research. Tweet this!

Animal testing

Non-animal models, such as cell and tissue culture, are used in addition to animal models, but they cannot replace all animal research.

An argument in favor of animal experimentation
Rated 3/5 based on 24 review
Arguments For Animal Research – Speaking of Research